THE THIN LINE BETWEEN HEALTHY AND AT-RISK YOUNG RUNNERS
Advice for Preventing the "Female Athlete Triad"

Interview of Kristin Cobb, PhD by Coach Mick
(Also published on kidsrunning.com and in the soon to be
released (Q3 2007) Gale publication "At Issue: Child Athletes")


  From Dr. Cobb: "Please remind your readers that the majority of children in this country are much more at risk for obesity these days than for eating disorders. Children who exercise and run regularly are reducing their risk for many chronic diseases in later life, so these behaviors are to be encouraged; as long as parents and coaches watch out for the signs of eating disorders, catch them early, and explain the severe consequences to girls who are starting these behaviors, I do believe that these problems are extremely preventable."  

Mick: Dr. Cobb, We have heard more and more reports recently about the importance of female runners keeping a healthy lifestyle.

Dr. Cobb: Running can be the cornerstone of a healthy lifestyle for your child, as it prevents depression, promotes confidence and self-esteem, and wards off many chronic diseases. However, girls who run are at risk for a serious disorder known as the "female athlete triad", which is a combination of disordered eating, lack of menstrual periods, and fragile bones. This syndrome may lead to early osteoporosis and spontaneous fractures, prolonged psychological difficulties with weight and food, and anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. The good news is that eating disorders and associated problems can be prevented, if young girls are educated about proper nutrition and encouraged to run in moderation.

Mick: What is osteoporosis and what causes it?

Dr. Cobb: Though we think of osteoporosis as an old person's disease, it is a disease that takes root in the young. Estrogen and nutrition are critical factors in a girl's bone development, and if they are not sufficient when a child is young, her bones will suffer in later life. The critical time for building the skeleton is in the early teenage years, just before and after puberty. Peak bone mass is achieved by a woman's late twenties. After this, she loses a little bone each year. Therefore, if a young girl fails to build sufficient bone in youth, she will develop thin bones (osteoporosis) much earlier in life than a woman with a healthy bone reserve.

Young women runners, who want to be lean for their sport, often restrict the amount or types of food that they eat. Meanwhile, they are burning hundreds of calories through exercise. The resulting energy drain may lead to menstrual disturbances - in trying to conserve energy, the body decreases its production of estrogen and prevents menstruation. Without sufficient estrogen and nutrition, bone development slows and bone loss may even occur.

If a girl is undernourished during the critical time when she's supposed to be building bone, these years of deprivation will be written into her skeleton, much like narrow tree rings reveal a history of drought. Though some recovery is possible, the damage can never be completely erased.

The longer disordered eating behaviors and menstrual irregularities persist, the greater the detriment to the skeleton. Some women runners in their twenties and thirties have bone strengths that would be normal for a 70-or 80-year old women. They may spontaneously break an arm, rib, leg, hip, or vertebra. Additionally, their chance for developing a stress fracture is high.

Mick: What are the most important components of a high performance diet? What MUST a female athlete be sure to eat and drink every day?

Dr. Cobb: There is no one "magic" food that will guarantee high performance. Most importantly, young female athletes should be discouraged from restricting their diets or becoming too rigid in their food choices. Female athletes must eat enough calories every day to sustain their energy output; the calories should come from a well-balanced, varied diet that includes not only fruits and vegetables (the foods we typically think of as "healthy"), but also sufficient fat and protein. Growing girls also need to get at least

1200-1500 mg. of calcium every day. This is most easily obtained from eating 3-5 servings of dairy products, such as yogurt, milk, and cheese. Other calcium-rich foods include leafy green vegetables, such as kale, calcium-enriched juices and cereals, and tofu. A calcium supplement may be warranted if a girl gets insufficient calcium in her diet.

Mick: Are there negative psychological aspects of these disorders?

Dr. Cobb: Beyond the physical problems, disordered eating also has adverse psychological consequences. Even after resuming menses, women recovering from the female athlete triad may still struggle with issues of food and weight. If untreated, women with the female athlete triad may also go on to develop full blown eating disorders, which have a high mortality rate. Therefore, preventing disordered eating altogether is greatly preferable to treatment after the fact.

Mick: OK, Let's talk about PREVENTING the Female Athlete Triad. At what age do prevention efforts need to begin?

Dr. Cobb: Girls can be at risk for developing the female athlete triad at a young age, and prevention efforts should focus on early adolescence. The majority of bone accrual occurs between the ages of 9 and 14 years. This coincides exactly with the time when girls are most at risk for developing disordered eating patterns and eating disorders. Because caloric requirements are highest when children are between 11-14 years old, restricted food intake during this period is more likely to cause energy deficiency.

Bone loss can never be completely reversed, so early diagnosis and intervention is critical. Also, it should be noted, that an analog to the female athlete triad (disordered eating, low sex steroids, and low bone strength) may exist in males, but this has not yet been established.

PREVENTION OF THE FEMALE ATHLETE TRIAD

1. EDUCATION

Education should aim to increase awareness of the female athlete triad and its consequences among coaches, athletes, parents, teachers, and sports physicians. Many young women are unaware of the potential harm of restrictive eating and menstrual irregularities. In one survey of college athletes, seventy percent of the women who were engaging in pathologic weight control behaviors thought this behavior was harmless. Awareness of long-term consequences might prevent girls and women from initiating these behaviors. Young runners may be more motivated by the immediate desire to prevent stress fractures and loss of training time than by the threat of early osteoporosis (which may seem very distant to a young woman).

Pre-pubertal girls should be prepared for the fact that they are going to gain weight and body fat during puberty and that this may initially affect their performance. Education efforts should attempt to dispel the myth that thinner is always better for performance. The optimal weight, for high performance, lies somewhere in between too heavy and too thin.


2. NUTRITION

Many of the nutritional messages that flood our society are geared toward the sedentary, overweight adult.

These messages promote restriction of calories and fat. These messages are not appropriate for kids who are running - especially girls who should be encouraged to eat nutrient-dense foods.

Mick: I agree that an athlete doesn't want to restrict her intake of calories. What are nutrient-dense foods?

Dr. Cobb: Nutrient-dense foods usually refer to foods that have a high amount of nutrients per calorie, as opposed to a food that is all sugar, for example.

Girls should take in adequate calories for their energy output. Eating a higher percentage of calories from

fat (more fat for the same number of calories) may also help women to maintain regular menstrual periods. Adequate amounts of vitamins C, D, and K, as well as zinc and protein are also important for bone growth.

Mick: Could you more clearly describe the types of fats you recommend?

Dr. Cobb: Our study did not evaluate different types of fats in terms of their efficacy in maintaining menstruation, so, in terms of promoting menstrual regularity, all fats are probably equally effective (a donut will do!). Of course, from a cardiovascular perspective, vegetable oils, nuts, avocados, and other sources of unsaturated fats are preferable to saturated fats.

Mick: Is there a formula for calculating adequate calorie intake?

Dr. Cobb: There are calculators that can be used to estimate basal metabolic rate (based on weight, body frame size and age, plus energy expended from activity (based on the type and intensity of activity). You may be able to find one of these formulas on various on-line diet sites, but a single formula may not work well for children and teens because it depends so much on their stage of growth. The USRDA recommends about 2200 kcal per day for normal 11-18 year old girls, but this does not factor in added activity such as running. A rough guideline is to add 100 kcal per mile run per day.

Mick: Can you speak a little about calcium intake?

Dr. Cobb: While eating enough calcium (1500 mg/day) is important for bone development, eating calcium-rich foods is not sufficient to ensure bone health. Estrogen is also a key factor in building strong bones, and excess calcium will not prevent bone loss in a woman who is not menstruating or is undernourished.

Mick: How could we educate parents and athletes to ensure the proper balance of estrogen? Could you explain how to manage this?

Dr. Cobb: Estrogen balance is hard to monitor other than making sure that a woman is menstruating regularly (or gets her first period on time). Estrogen should be normal if a woman is eating right, but it's hard to give advice beyond this.

3. BONE-STIMULATING EXERCISES

High -impact exercise stimulates bone growth in children, particularly if it occurs before puberty. Therefore, exercise in childhood can help maximize peak bone density. Jumping puts higher forces on bone and stimulates more bone growth than running. Young runners should be encouraged to add jumping exercises and sports that involve jumping, such as basketball, soccer, and gymnastics, to their fitness routine.

WARNING SIGNS FOR THE FEMALE ATHLETE TRIAD

Some signs of disordered eating are;
- In older girls, delayed menarche (first period) and missed menstrual periods
- Restrictive eating behaviors; avoidance of certain foods
- Secretive eating
- Sudden weight loss or failure to make normal weight goals for age
- Obsession with food and/or weight
- Excessive exercise
- Signs of purging
- Signs of low bone strength:
1. In older girls, delayed menarche (first period) and missed menstrual periods
2. Stress fractures can be a sign of low bone strength.
3. A bone density test is the best way to determine bone strength.

Mick: As a parent or coach, what types of annual testing would you recommend? Is there a link between low iron and these problems?

Dr. Cobb: A yearly bone density test is not necessary for most young women. A bone density test would only be recommended for women who have amenorrhea, fractures, or an overt eating disorder. Low iron may reflect nutritional deficiencies, but low iron per se does not have a large effect on bone health.

Mick: Did you read the section on kidsrunning.com on "What the elites eat?" What do you think of that series?

Dr. Cobb: This looks great; it's especially good for young women to see that elite women athletes eat a full lunch that includes high-calorie and high-fat foods like nuts and peanut butter and cookies, as well as dairy foods such as yogurt.

Kristin Cobb does research on the female athlete triad at Stanford University. She used to compete in track and cross country in New England, but now just runs leisurely on the sunny trails of California.




RETURN TO INDEX